|
Nine:
An International Community
The
Peoples of the Region
"A
man is all sorts of baggage,
the most difficult to be
transported," wrote Scotland’s
Adam Smith in the 18th century.
Yet, as history indicates,
between 1880 and 1914, millions
of people left their homelands
in search of greater economic
opportunity, freedom and
peace. The migration from
Europe to North America
in that period has been
described as "the mightiest
movement of people in modem
history." Western Canada
be-came the destination
of several million immigrants,
not only from Europe but
from other parts of the
world, who were attracted
by the promises of a better
life in the "Last Best West."
The result was a unique
model of ethno-cultural
cooperation without assimilation.
As the years passed and
the dust from arriving newcomers
settled, and after often
bitter experiences of adaptation,
prejudice and discrimination,
a truly international community
has developed in the region.
The
mosaic analogy is particularly
apt for Western Canada because
literally dozens of ethnic
groups today resemble inlays
of differing size, distribution
and colour in a larger design.
Their diversity of language,
dress, culture and custom
has created a kaleidoscope
in our West and North. The
term ‘mosaic’ itself was
first applied to Canada
by an American writer, Victoria
Hayward, who wrote of our
Prairies in 1922, "The New
Canadians, representing
many lands and widely separated
sections of Old Europe,
have contributed to the
prairie provinces a variety
in the way of Church architecture.
Cupolas and domes distinctly
Eastern, almost Turkish,
startle one above the tops
of Manitoba maples or the
bush of the river banks....
Here and there in the corner
of a wheat field, at the
cross-section of a prairie
highway, one sees, as in
Quebec, the tall, uplifted
Crucifix set up. It is indeed
a mosaic of vast dimensions
and great breadth, essayed
of the Prairie."
Since
the beginning of the twentieth
century, Western Canada
has continued to develop
its culturally pluralistic,
multi-political and multi-religious
form. This is partly because
no cultural community is
numerically dominant; there
are several large groups,
including the English, German,
Ukrainian, Scottish, Irish
and French-Canadians. Members
of every cultural community,
including the larger ones,
believe people are of equal
worth and that all should
have the freedom to choose
their own life-style. A
pattern of permissive differentiation,
whether in religion, political
ideology or language, instead
of assimilation, emerged
early in the West and set
very firmly. More than in
any other region of Canada,
multiculturalism began as
an acknowledged reality
here and flourished as the
decades went by.
The
prairie population grew
from about 400,000 in 1901
to 2.4 million by 1931.
A passenger on a CPR train
disembarking in Winnipeg
in 1914 would encounter
on Main Street languages
and people from virtually
every corner of the earth.
As the historian Gerald
Friesen points Out, "almost
half of all prairie residents
at the start of the First
World War had been born
in another country, and
the proportion was still
one in three as late as
1931. Those who were British
by ‘origin’ (a census term
defined by the ancestral
roots of a family’s male
line) had similarly declined
to about 50% of the prairie
total (of this group, half
were English, one-quarter
Scots) while the various
Eastern European groups
(Ukrainian, Austro-Hungarian,
Polish and Russian) numbered
about 20%, and Western Europeans
(German, Dutch, French,
including French Canadians)
also numbered about 20%."
Five
separate waves of immigrants
swept over Western Canada.
The first, resulting from
the fur trade, created the
French-and English-speaking
Métis. The second, occurring
during the final years of
the nineteenth century after
Confederation, consisted
mainly of British Canadian
families, although there
were also Icelanders, Mennonites,
Jews and others. The largest
wave swept in between 1897
and 1913, bringing roughly
equal numbers of settlers
from other provinces of
Canada, Britain, America
and Continental Europe together
with a few Chinese and Japanese.
The fourth, arriving during
the 1920s, was essentially
an extension of the third
in terms of points of origin.
The fifth, persons arriving
since World War II, included
Europeans displaced by the
war and, after 1962, immigrants
from Asia and the Pacific
Rim nations.
Clifford
Sifton and his belief in
the potential of the West
deserve much credit for
the diversity and vigour
of the immigrants who came
between 1897 and 1930. As
immigration minister from
1896 to 1905, he spent large
sums of public money attracting
farmers from Europe, Britain
and America. Although he
personally believed in the
assimilation of newcomers
to Anglo-Canadian norms,
no one can fault him for
not casting his net to include
farm communities virtually
everywhere, most notably
in Central and Eastern Europe.
His successor as immigration
minister, Edmonton’s Frank
Oliver, reduced recruiting
in Europe and increased
it in the United Kingdom.
In consequence, more British
immigrants came after 1905,
including an astonishing
80,000 children from English
slums whose passages were
assisted by British charities.
Robert Borden’s Conservative
government kept the immigration
door open to unskilled English
immigrants after 1911 but
continued a Laurier regulation
measure of 1908 which in
practice excluded most Asians
and Arabs. In 1925, Prime
Minister Mackenzie King
allowed the Canadian National
and Canadian Pacific Railways
again to recruit farmers
in Central and Eastern Europe;
as a result, almost 370,000
Europeans arrived in Canada
during the following six
years. Between 1931 and
1941, the immigration gates
were all but closed to everyone
as a reaction to the huge
unemployment created by
the Great Depression.
By
the time of the 1986 national
census, the population mix
of the four western provinces
was significantly different
from that of Canada as a
whole. In all three prairie
provinces less than forty
percent of the residents
claim a single country of
family origin from Britain
or France. British Columbia
is slightly over forty percent,
whereas in Ontario and all
four Atlantic provinces
well over forty percent
of the residents assert
a single family origin from
the British Isles. In three
of them (Nova Scotia, Prince
Edward Island and Newfoundland)
that proportion is over
sixty percent. In the profiles
which follow, I will highlight
the diversity of Western
Canadians through glances
at a number of ethnocultural
communities. The sketches
feature some of those who
have arrived relatively
recently but are already
making a major contribution
to the West, along with
groups of longer standing.
All have had to meet in
some measure the challenges
of pioneering and all have
responded in their own "Western"
way.
More
than seventy distinct ethno-cultural
groups can now be identified’
in Western Canada. To tell
their respective stories
within a framework of one
chapter is thus impossible.
While attempting to provide
an overview of the almost
infinite variety of the
region, I am forced to focus
on only some representative
groups which in my opinion
reflect well the essence
of the other Western Canadian
communities today. The singular
history of the Métis people
in Western Canada was recorded
in an earlier chapter. In
addition to the Métis, those
groups chosen for discussion
here appear to me to capture
the pioneering spirit of
all the first westbound
settlers who came, or are
coming, to start their lives
anew. The chapter concludes
with a discussion of the
role of bilingualism in
a multicultural region.
Scandinavians
Our
region is home to almost
80% of all Canadians who
claim Scandinavian ancestry:
130,000 Westerners are descended
entirely from Danes, Norwegians,
Swedes, or Icelanders, while
another 380,000 have some
Scandinavian forebears.
Most Canadian Westerners
of Scandinavian origin came
to the West as American
immigrants between 1893
and 1914, when nearly a
hundred thousand moved to
the Canadian Prairies. Many
of them settled in fertile
parts of central Alberta
and Saskatchewan, where
they became major players
in the formation of the
dairy industry. From the
beginning, Anglo-Westerners
viewed all Scandinavians
as close cousins. This was
encouraged by such familiar
images as Shakespeare’s
Hamlet, Prince of Denmark.
Relations between the historical
monarchs of Norway and Scotland
were so close that Scotland’s
Hebrides held the tombs
of eight Norwegian kings.
And Hans Christian Anderson’s
fairy tales were as dear
to Anglo-Canadian children
as to Scandinavian ones.
Scandinavians
were among the first settlers
who ventured into the North-West
at the beginning of the
nineteenth century. The
earliest Norwegians were
brought by Lord Selkirk
in 1815 to build a portage
for his Selkirk colony on
the Red River. At the north
end of Lake Winnipeg they
established Norway House,
which remains a commercial
centre to this day. One
Norwegian, Peter Dahl, stayed
to homestead. During the
mid-l9th century, the Hudson’s
Bay Company continued to
recruit boatmen from Norway,
but the first large influx
came later from the south.
Between 1871 and 1895, 660,000
Swedes, 330,000 Norwegians
and 160,000 Danes reached
the United States. Most
of them settled in the Midwest,
although many had arrived
first in Montreal by steamship.
When
the price of American farmland
later began to rise, the
promise of free homesteads
in the Canadian West brought
many Scandinavians northwards.
The first group were Swedes
who settled near Minnedosa,
Manitoba, and Stockholm,
Saskatchewan, in the 1880s.
Norwegians in turn founded
Numedal in southern Manitoba,
and New Norway, Camrose,
Olds, Lacombe, Wetaskiwin,
Sundre and other centres
in Alberta in the mid-1890s.
Calgary’s first major industry,
a sawmill run by a predominantly
Norwegian crew, was founded
in 1886. Another group of
Norwegian fisherman founded
Hagensborg in 1893 near
Bella Coola on the British
Columbia coast. Most Scandinavians
settled in Saskatchewan
during the early twentieth
century. Their practical
experience in the American
Midwest proved an excellent
training for success in
the age of wheat.
Icelanders
began to arrive in Manitoba
in the last quarter of the
nineteenth century from
an island homeland where
entire villages had been
swept away by volcanoes.
In 1875, a group of them
chose to settle in Gimli
("paradise") on the shores
of Lake Winnipeg for various
reasons, including freedom
from prairie grasshoppers,
an easy waterway to Winnipeg,
an abundance of fish in
the lake and the availability
of a large tract of land.
The new settlement, with
its own administration and
Icelandic law, was called
"New Iceland," and about
1,200 people moved there.
They founded a school, churches
and an Icelandic-language
newspaper. A few years later,
Governor General Lord Dufferin
visited Gimli and in praising
the Icelanders noted that
each one of the new homes
he had entered contained
"a library of twenty or
thirty volumes; and I am
informed that there is scarcely
a child amongst you who
cannot read and write."
In time, many Icelanders
moved to Winnipeg; that
city and the province of
Manitoba remain the centre
of their settlement in Canada.
By 1986, still about half
of all Icelandic Canadians
continued to live in Manitoba,
and Vancouver attracted
a good portion of those
who left.
The
first Danes in Canada reached
Hudson’s Bay in 1619 when
their ship captain, Jens Munck, was looking for the
Northwest Passage to the
Orient. His attempt to found
New Denmark at what is now
Churchill, Manitoba, expired
when 61 crew members died
of scurvy, although Munck
and two others somehow managed
to sail back to Denmark.
At the beginning of the
twentieth century, Danish
settlers reached the Prairies
in response to the call
of Canadian Pacific Railway
land agents and publicity
in Denmark by the Canadian
government. In 1903, Danish
immigration from Nebraska
began when two Danes, Jens
and Henry Larsen, returned
from the Canadian prairies
to report rich forests and
grazing lands. Danish settlers
were equally successful
on the Prairies and transposed
from Denmark both their
system of agricultural cooperation
and training in Danish Folk
High Schools. In the 1950s,
a number of Danish professionals
came to settle in Western
Canadian cities. Difficulties
arose in maintaining the
Danish language and culture
beyond the first generation
because of the scattered
nature of the Danish population,
intermarriages with other
cultural communities, and
the fact that so many of
them had begun in the United
States to adapt to the North
American way of life.
Swedish
immigration to Central Canada
began in the 1850’s because
of famines and land shortages
in Sweden, but most immigrants
soon left for the milder
climate and readily available
farmland in the United States.
Later, many re-crossed the
frontier, some to work as
miners and lumberjacks and
others to help build the
Canadian Pacific Railway
line westward. Upon the
railway’s completion in
1885, Winnipeg became the
centre of Swedish immigration
for all of Canada. By 1911,
however, Alberta also had
significant Swedish populations
in Strathcona, Red Deer
and Medicine Hat. Saskatchewan
became the most popular
western province for Swedes
and by 1931 a quarter of
all Swedes in Canada lived
in the wheat province. With
the outbreak of World War
II, many prairie Swedes
relocated to British Columbia
to work in its war industries.
Today 62,000 Canadians with
Swedish origins live in
British Columbia.
The
Norwegian settlement in
Western Canada was prompted
by mounting debts and a
lack of land in the American
Midwest. The Canadian Prairies
offered a second chance
and many thousands moved
to Alberta and Saskatchewan.
In 1912, some of these moved
to Alberta’s Peace River
district around Valhalla
and were later joined by
others from further south
during the crop failure
of the 1930s. Many Norwegian-Canadians
on the Prairies remained
in farming occupations until
much of the prairie topsoil
simply blew away in the
1930s. Many were then forced
to move to other parts of
Canada or to return to Norway.
A number moved to the lower
mainland of British Columbia,
and by the 1986 census,
British Columbia had 54,000
part-origin and 20,000 sole-origin
Norwegian-Canadians, the
highest number for any province
in the country.
The
Scandinavians of Western
Canada adapted readily to
their surroundings and quickly
became part of rural and
later urban Western Canada
conditions. Today, they
are still playing vital
roles in the growth and
development of the region.
South
Asians
Western
Canadian South Asians include
people from India; Pakistan,
Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and
Afghanistan, but also many
whose families were established,
often for generations, in
Africa and the Caribbean,
though having South Asian
roots. According to the
1986 census, Western Canada
contains approximately 110,000
sole-origin South Asians
and another 21,000 who claim
part South Asian family
beginnings.
The
cultural, religious and
linguistic backgrounds of
these communities are probably
even more diverse than the
heritage of their fellow
residents from Western and
Eastern Europe. India alone
has fifteen official languages
and a hundred or so minor
ones, several hundred million
Hindus, three times more
Muslims than there are Canadians,
and millions of Sikhs and
Christians.
Until
the 1960s, few South Asians
lived anywhere in Canada
beyond British Columbia.
The first to arrive in the
lower mainland in 1904 were
a group of self-reliant
Sikhs from the Punjab in
Northern India who had learned
of the province from Indian
soldiers passing through
Canada on their way to the
coronation of King Edward
VII in Britain. Relying
on the then well-established
principle that immigration
within the British Empire
must be unimpeded, other
Sikhs attempted to follow.
Future prime minister William
Lyon Mackenzie King, at
that time deputy minister
of labour, quickly devised
a way to get around this:
his 1908 order-in-council
prescribed that any immigrant
from India must reach Canada
on a "continuous voyage."
Since there was at the time
no direct steamship connection
between Canada and India,
Sikh immigration immediately
ended.
In
1914, a wealthy British
Columbia Sikh, Gurdit Singh,
challenged the regulation
by chartering the Komagata
Maru to bring about 400
Sikhs and Muslim Punjabis
to Canada. The ship was
forbidden by Canadian officials
to land in Vancouver and
the passengers were forced
to remain on board for two
months while the lawyers
argued that King’s regulation
violated both the Magna
Carta and the British North
America Act. This effort
ultimately failed, and the
arrival of a Canadian naval
cruiser alongside compelled
the would-be immigrants
to return to India. The
measure would bar virtually
all South Asians immigrants
to Canada until it was rescinded
in 1947.
In
1951, under pressure from
newly-independent India,
Pakistan and Ceylon, the
Louis St Laurent cabinet
agreed to some token immigration
from each of the three countries.
In 1967, under the government
of Prime Minister Lester
Pearson, the quota system
was finally replaced by
a point system which admitted
newcomers on the basis of
skills, education and economic
criteria. In consequence,
large numbers of South Asian
teachers, professors, medical
doctors and other professionals
settled in major western
cities during the 1960s
and 1970s.
Strong
family, religious and cultural
practices remain a distinctive
feature for South Asian
Westerners regardless of
their particular country
of origin. Marriages often
occur within the same community
and partners of both sexes
may come from the Indian
subcontinent. Most marriages
arranged by parents seem
to prove remarkably durable
and happy. Many South Asian
young people in the West
have adopted the general
lifestyle of other urbanites,
but also maintain their
traditional culture and
worship.
South
Asians are the most varied
of all ethno-cultural communities
in the West. Many are first-generation
Canadians and some worry
with good reason that discrimination
can deny them employment
opportunities commensurate
with their efforts and abilities.
On the optimistic side,
the passing of each year
provides a larger proportion
of South Asian Westerners
who arc long-term residents
of the region. The immigration
policies and practices which
kept a talented community
tiny for decades are now
gone or going. The chain
migration of family and
friends is growing, and
carries with it a range
of positive consequences.
Scots
According
to the 1986 census, almost
300,000 Westerners claimed
Scotland as their only place
of family origin and another
1.2 million persons included
it as one of their origins.
Scots are thus, along with
the English, Germans, Ukrainians,
French-Canadians and Irish,
among the largest communities
in the West. For the 1971
census, Statistics Canada
ignored centuries of distinct
Scottish history to group
them with the English, Irish
and Welsh as "British."
But Western Canadians of
Scottish origin felt entitled
to a separate treatment
of their ethnicity, settlement
and immigration, largely
because of their history
of antipathy toward England.
True, Scotland finally disappeared
as an independent nation
in 1707, but few Scots altered
their coolness toward London
thereafter and many maintained
close ties with Europe,
most notably France.
In
the eighteenth and nineteenth
centuries, moreover, had
not Scottish thinkers such
as David Hume and Adam Smith
completely reshaped English
thought in economics, philosophy,
and science? As the Manitoba
historian, J.M. Bumsted,
puts it, the "English might
have had the political power,
but Scots dominated the
life of the mind." A major
reason was the superiority
of Scotland’s educational
institutions and the insistence
of its reformers on achieving
both a fully literate population
and a curriculum which stressed
contemporary needs. Scotland’s
most important gift to Western
Canada and civilization
as a whole was probably
the concept of the "democratic
intellect" based on ability
rather than family financial
resources.
Another
Scottish gift to the world
was hundreds of thousands
of "surplus" people from
both the Highlands and Lowlands
of Scotland who helped to
populate many corners of
the world while romanticizing
their former homeland. The
first to reach Western Canada
arrived in Red River in
1812 through Hudson Bay,
under the sponsorship of
Lord Selkirk, to lay the
foundation of a new colony.
It grew until by 1820 it
was firmly rooted as the
first farming settlement
in the West. The Highland
clearances at the end of
the 18th century by absentee
landlords, who concluded
that cattle and sheep were
more profitable than tenant
farmers, produced thousands
of immigrants for Canada.
Crofters, whose homes had
been burned to ensure their
departure, responded particularly
well to advertisements for
free passage, free land
on arrival and free provisions
for a year.
Once
in Central Canada, the Scots
quickly established a reputation
for mutual support in religion,
politics, business and education,
and earnestness and honesty
in personal conduct. The
Scottish presence in the
West has been lengthy and
highly significant. Scots
such as Alexander Mackenzie,
Roderick Mackenzie, Simon
Fraser and James Macleod
tapped the West’s fur resources,
explored and mapped waterways,
and established many forts
and trading posts which
later became permanent settlements.
Approximately
240,000 Scots were among
the newcomers who arrived
in Canada during the first
fifteen years of the 20th
century. Another 200,000
came to Canada between 1919
and 1930; 147,000 more arrived
between 1946 and 1960. Many
came directly to farms and
cities of the West; some
stopped for a generation
in Atlantic or Central Canada
before moving to Western
Canada. Once here, most
western Scots gravitated
to cities and non-agricultural
employment. There has been
a good deal of assimilation
of Scots within the greater
Western Canadian community.
The use of Highland Gaelic
has all but disappeared;
memories of the "old country"
have faded for all but the
most recently arrived. On
the other hand, most Scots
in the West today still
consider themselves to be
a distinctive tile in the
western mosaic. Among themselves,
perhaps at the annual Robbie
Burns suppers, some will
even argue they have dominated
the economic, cultural and
political life of Western
Canada. Others will quickly
reply that Burns, that most
revered of Scots, would
mock such vain boasting!
Chinese
Immigration
to the West was largely
a movement from Europe --
through the ports of Eastern
and Central Canada, but
many people came through
British Columbia from the
nations of the Far East.
Among these are numbered
the Chinese, a group which
has participated in the
building of Western Canada
since the mid-19th century.
Western
Canada in 1986 had approximately
170,000 persons of solely
Chinese origin and about
22,000 more of partly Chinese
descent. Seven in ten single-origin
Chinese Western Canadians
live in British Columbia,
and fully 100,000 of these
reside in the Vancouver
area. A little less than
half of all Canadians of
single Chinese origin live
in the four western provinces,
the Yukon and Northwest
Territories.
Chinese
Canadians born outside Canada
have come from many countries.
The 1981 census shows that
in this group 24% were born
in Taiwan; 23% in China;
9% in Vietnam; 4% in Malaysia
or Singapore; and 34% elsewhere,
primarily Hong Kong. Eighty-seven
percent of those born outside
Canada entered Canada during
the 1965-81 period and in
recent years approximately
13,000 have entered Canada,
many from Hong Kong, as
entrepreneurs. The unemployment
rate for both Chinese men
and women was at the time
of the 1981 census less
than that for Canadian men
and women as a whole. Considerably
more Chinese Canadians (28%)
than all Canadians (16%)
have some university education.
Western
Canadians of Chinese origin
are part of the huge diaspora
of more than eight million
"overseas Chinese" who have
prospered from South Asia
to the Caribbean. As late
as the sixteenth century,
China had the highest standard
of living on earth. During
the eighteenth century,
its population more than
doubled, reaching 430 million
by 1850. When Europeans
forcibly opened China’s
markets in the 19th century,
its cottage cloth industry
was all but destroyed by
machine-made foreign cloth.
A migration of young men
became necessary to help
feed their closely-knit
families who were left at
home.
The
first of these men from
China came to British Columbia
in 1858, lured by the Fraser
River gold rush, and by
1860 approximately 4,000
of them lived in the lower
mainland of the colony.
Some mined, others sold
vegetables or wood, or operated
restaurants and laundries.
The legal equality in the
workplace of those who stayed
after the gold rush was
removed by the B.C. provincial
legislature in 1878 when
it unanimously resolved
that persons of origin in
China could no longer be
hired on provincial public
works -- a rule which astonishingly
remained in effect until
after World War II. The
franchise was denied to
them in 1872.
Nonetheless,
as many as 17,000 Chinese
came to B.C. between 1881
and 1884 to assume a Herculean
part in the completion of
the Canadian Pacific rail
line between the Fraser
Canyon and Vancouver. As
the project neared completion,
the B.C. provincial government
encouraged them to leave
the region through such
measures as a $10 head tax
on all Chinese, banning
the removal of dead bodies
back to China, denying Chinese
the right to buy provincial
Crown land, and prohibiting
further immigration from
China. Prime Minister Macdonald’s
government in Ottawa played
its part by imposing a $50
head tax on all Chinese
entering Canada after 1886.
In 1900, Prime Minister
Laurier raised the head
tax to $100, and in 1904
to $500. In 1923,
the government of Mackenzie
King barred all Chinese
immigration, and it did
not begin again until the
legislation was finally
repealed in 1947.
The
combination of legislated
and other discrimination
against the Chinese in British
Columbia and better opportunities
to establish small businesses
elsewhere in Canada, by
1921 had caused an estimated
40% of the 40,000 Chinese
then resident in Canada
to move eastward, some as
far as Newfoundland. Virtually
every prairie town soon
had a Chinese restaurant
and laundry. The three prairie
legislatures proved not
immune to anti-Chinese propaganda
seeping over the mountains.
The Saskatchewan assembly
disenfranchised Chinese
as early as 1908, which
meant in practice that they
could not vote in federal
elections either or join
professions whose associations
required members to be registered
voters. The prairie fever
here reached a sufficiently
high temperature that the
Saskatchewan and Manitoba
governments, even before
British Columbia’s, barred
Chinese restaurants from
hiring white women out of
a preposterous fear that
they would be introduced
to opium and sold into white
slavery.
Between
1924 and 1946, only eight
Chinese immigrants entered
Canada because of Mackenzie
King’s Chinese exclusion
law of 1923. Many of the
Chinese men already resident
in Canada thus aged without
families in Canada. Ironically,
events of World War II helped
the Canadian Chinese cause
because white Canadian sympathy
for China grew markedly
as a result of the Japanese
aggression there. As the
historians Jin Tan and Patricia
Roy point out, "[During
the war,] racial prejudice
be-came unfashionable."
The Vancouver Parks Board,
for example, repealed its
rule that Chinese persons
could swim at a public pool
only during a specified
two-hour period once weekly.
The legislature of Saskatchewan
restored the franchise in
1944 and in 1945 British
Columbia enfranchised everyone
who had served in either
World War, including the
Chinese but not the Japanese.
The public on the coast
generally welcomed the repeal
of Ottawa’s Chinese Immigration
Act in 1947.
In
fact, many Chinese Westerners
continued to face real difficulty
in entering Canada after
1947. With the violent events
accompanying the creation
of the People’s Republic
of China in 1949, some quite
understandably entered Canada
illegally. In 1962, a federal
amnesty was offered to illegal
immigrants of "good sound
character," and by the time
the program ended in 1973
more than 12,000 had changed
their status. Racial discrimination
in immigration officially
disappeared in 1967 when
new regulations began to
screen potential immigrants
on a "point system" which
reflected their prospective
economic contribution to
Canada. This put the Chinese
on an equal footing with
other immigrants. Between
1972 and 1978, almost 80%
of our Chinese immigrants
came from Hong Kong, most
choosing to live in suburbs
rather than in Chinatowns.
The so-called boat people
of 1979 and the early 1980’s
included Vietnamese, Laotians
and Cambodians as well as
Chinese, and among them,
Tan and Roy note, "were
urban professionals, both
men and women, once-wealthy
businessmen and persons
of influence in their own
countries as well as poor
illiterate peasants and
fisherfolk." The warm response
by Western Canadians and
Canadians generally contrasted
markedly with that given
to Chinese newcomers earlier.
Today,
a large number of Western
Canadians of Chinese origin
are entrepreneurs and professionals.
A majority of them are in
sales, services and other
white-collar work. Most
of them think of themselves
as Canadians first and Chinese
second. Alone among all
cultural groups in Canada,
however, they know that
their families were forced
to pay an entry fee (1885-1923)
and were effectively barred
from immigration by legislation
(1923-1947). Attitudes have
finally changed throughout
Canada and institutionalized
racism is gone. No longer
do whites expect them or
anyone to be "assimilated."
They can now preserve and
celebrate their cultural
identity and remain both
Canadian and Chinese in
whatever proportion they
choose.
Ukrainians
The
four western provinces hold
300,000, or approximately
three quarters, of all Canadians
who give their sole origin
as Ukrainian and 370,000,
or 68% of those who give
it as one of their family
origins. Most Westerners
originating in Ukraine came
in one of three waves. The
largest by far was the 1891-1914
migration of farmers from
Galicia and Bukovina, provinces
in the Austro-Hungarian
Empire, who sought to escape
poverty, malnutrition, shrinking
landholdings, primitive
farming practices and growing
indebtedness. Thousands
of them took 160-acre homesteads
in Western Canada on paying
a $10 registration fee.
Clifford Sifton was genuinely
enthusiastic about immigrants
from Ukraine, and most of
the estimated 170,000 Ukrainians
who came before World War
I settled in the Canadian
Prairies. By 1921, Manitoba
had the largest Ukrainian
population in Canada, followed
by Saskatchewan and Alberta.
The hardships were great:
virgin land to break and
frequently forests to cut
by hand, a new language,
few roads or local improvements,
mammoth distances and farm
isolation, mosquitoes in
summer and bitter cold in
winter, nonexistent or rare
medical and social services.
Immigrants from Ukraine
were among the first settlers
who broke the land and helped
lay the foundation of the
region’s wealth. Therefore,
they are one of our founding
peoples, central to the
West’s beginnings.
The
1914-1918 period was complicated
for Ukrainians in Western
Canada because of prejudice
and discrimination on the
part of the dominant Anglo-Celtic
population. The federal
government enacted a number
of measures to segregate
and monitor the activities
of immigrants-from enemy
countries. Public hostility
and official sanctions were
directed at Germans and
Ukrainians, who were now
considered "enemy aliens."
The 1914 War Measures Act
led to the internment in
concentration camps of about
6,000 Austro--Hungarians,
the overwhelming majority
of whom were Ukrainians.
As Vera Lysenko notes in
Men In Sheepskin Coats,
during World War I,
"One repressive measure
followed another, directed
against bewildered Ukrainians.
Thousands of harmless ‘Galicians’
were rounded up by the police
and herded into concentration
camps.... The slightest
criticism on the part of
a Ukrainian and he was dragged
from home, factory or hotel
and placed in an internment
camp."
There
were other forms of suppression.
English-Ukrainian bilingual
classrooms on the Prairies
were abolished during the
war. Some Ukrainian publications
were censored or banned.
Most outrageous was the
Wartime Elections Act of
1917, which disenfranchised
every enemy alien naturalized
since 1902.
In
1918, an independent Ukrainian
state was proclaimed; it
survived only until 1920.
In 1922, most Ukrainian
territory was incorporated
into the Soviet Union, with
substantial segments of
population falling under
Polish, Czechoslovakian
or Romanian rule.
Almost
68,000 persons came to Canada
between the two world wars,
most from Galicia and Bukovina
as they had earlier. In
contrast to the first wave
of immigrants, the inter-war
Ukrainians were better educated
and more nationally conscious.
This group had a much easier
time in Western Canada because
immigrant aid societies
of the Ukrainian community
already present assisted
both financially and morally.
Tragically, Ukrainians were
dropped to a "non-preferred"
status by Ottawa during
the 1930s; this may have
prevented the escape to
Canada of at least some
of the estimated seven million
who were deliberately starved
to death by Stalin during
that period. Very few Ukrainians
managed to reach this country
until after World War II.
During
the Great Depression, Ukrainians
suffered at least as much
as any other group in Canadian
society. As jobs became
scarce, discrimination against
"foreigners" became a fearful
reality. The western historian
James Gray catches in his
Winter Years what
many non-Anglo-Saxon Westerners
faced during the 1930’s
in addition to the Great
Depression: "For them [Ukrainians,
Poles and Jews] Winnipeg
was far from being a city
of 250,000 in which they
too were free to search
for work. As much as two-thirds
of it was barred and bolted
against them.... Anyone
with a Ukrainian or Polish
name had almost no chance
of employment except rough
manual labour. The oil companies,
banks, mortgage companies,
financial and stock brokers,
and most retail and mercantile
companies except the Hudson’s
Bay Company discriminated
against all non-Anglo-Saxons.
For the young Ukrainians
and Poles there was a possible
solution if they could beat
the accent handicap. They
could change their names.
So they changed their names,
sometimes formally and legally,
but mostly informally and
casually."
During
World War II, an estimated
40,000 Ukrainians, or more
than ten percent of the
entire community in Canada,
enlisted in the Canadian
armed forces despite the
fact that one of our allies
(the USSR) had oppressed
their people for centuries.
After the war, many thousands
of Ukrainians who had been
deported to labour farms,
concentration camps or German
factories in Western Europe
simply refused to return
to Ukraine, which was then
entirely part of the Soviet
Union. A tragic repatriation
of many thousands was finally
stopped, and the remaining
refugees from Ukraine were
granted "displaced person"
status and resettled abroad.
The Ukrainian Canadian Committee
urged the King and St. Laurent
governments to accept refugees.
Between 1947 and 1953, approximately
34,000 Ukrainians came to
Canada, many well-educated
professionals.
A
major problem for Ukrainians
in Western Canada since
World War II has been the
declining use of their language.
Between 1951 and 1971, the
use of Ukrainian as a mother
tongue in the 0-9 age group
dropped from 61 to 21 percent.
In the 10-19 group, the
drop was even worse, from
85 to 30%. Finally, the
community pushed successfully
to have Ukrainian restored
as a language of study in
prairie schools. In Alberta
this was achieved in 1959;
in Manitoba, in 1961. By
the 1970s, all three prairie
provinces allowed Ukrainian
as a language of instruction
for up to half of the school
day. The community also
advocated a multicultural
Canada to the Royal Commission
on Bilingualism and Biculturalism
in the early 1960s. By 1971,
in large measure because
of pressure created by Western
Canadians of a non-British,
non-French background and
led by the Ukrainian Canadian
Committee, Canada became
for the first time a nation
with two official languages,
but no official culture.
A fuller recognition of
the culturally diverse nature
of Canada is still needed,
argue Ukrainian Canadians,
who as a group face the
possibility of assimilation
in Canada and russification
in Ukraine. The Ukrainian
Canadian Committee, a coalition
dedicated to democratic
principles, to promoting
Ukrainian cultural goals
in Canada and to supporting
the aspirations of Ukrainians
in the USSR, has led the
successful campaign to ensure
that their community is
not assimilated in Canada.
During
1988, Ukrainian communities
around the world are celebrating
the Millennium of the official
adoption of Christianity
in Ukraine. In 988, Volodymyr,
the Grand Prince of Kievan-Rus
(modern day Ukraine) had
the inhabitants of Kiev
baptised, thus bringing
his country into the Christian
fold. A thousand years later,
Christianity continues to
enrich the lives of the
people of Ukraine dispersed
throughout the world. During
the past 300 years, Ukraine
lost its independence and
there have been difficult
periods of government repression
in the Soviet Ukraine, but
the Ukrainian Church still
exists there, although clandestinely.
Having
survived against all conceivable
odds, Christianity would
appear yet to sustain the
hopes of the Ukrainian nation
and to serve as a source
of strength for millions
of Ukrainians living abroad.
Pope John Paul II observed
in a letter to the late
Ukrainian Catholic Cardinal
Josyf Slipyi: "...When Ukrainian
sons and daughters leave
their own country, they
remain always, even as immigrant
settlers, bound with their
church, which with its tradition,
language and liturgy, is
for them a spiritual legacy
that continually refreshes
and nurtures the soul."
Japanese
Of
the 54,000 Canadians wholly
or partly of Japanese origin,
31,000, or about 57%,
lived in Western Canada
at the time of the 1986
census. Many Japanese Canadians
are found in the major western
cities, with over 15,000
in Vancouver. This shows
a significant dispersal,
since in 1941 95% of Canada’s
23,450 Japanese lived in
British Columbia.
Immigration
from Japan began in 1877,
nine years after the Emperor
Meiji ascended the Japanese
throne. He actively encouraged
trade and travel with the
West. The first immigrant,
Manzo Nagano, settled in
British Columbia. By 1896,
approximately 1,000 Japanese,
mostly males, were working
in British Columbia in fishing,
mining, logging, railway
construction and farming.
By 1911, the community had
grown to about 9,000.
Active
discrimination against Japanese
began in 1895 when the British
Columbia legislature took
away the vote from Japanese
Canadians. They remained
disenfranchised for over
fifty years. In 1907, at
Ottawa’s insistence, the
Japanese government agreed
to limit the number of male
immigrants to 400 pen year.
In the same year, a mob
fired up by anti-Asian agitators
who wanted to keep British
Columbia white, attacked
the Japanese and Chinese
parts of Vancouver. In 1928,
Japan agreed to reduce the
how of immigrants even further
to 150 persons yearly. Japanese
Canadians, whether immigrants
called Issei or Canadian
born called Nisei, were
also excluded by provincial
law from most professions,
the provincial public service
and teaching. The minimum
wage law of the province
authorized a substantially
smaller wage for Asian Canadians.
British
Columbia remained essentially
a ghetto for Japanese Canadians
throughout the 1920s and
1930s. Even those who had
fought for Canada in World
War I were denied the vote.
Ottawa exacerbated the already
poor conditions in the 1920’s,
as historian Ann Sunahara
points out, "[by limiting]
the number of fishing licences
to Japanese Canadians, thus
denying many Japanese Canadians
their traditional livelihood.
During the Great Depression,
Japanese Canadians received
only a fraction of the social
assistance that white applicants
received and medical facilities
were segregated." Second-generation
Japanese Canadians with
university degrees found
themselves unemployable
on the coast except as store
clerks within the Japanese
community or as labourers
in sawmills and pulp mills.
The
meagre economic gains of
Japanese Canadians, won
through 40 years of hard
labour, vanished swiftly
after Japan’s attack on
Pearl Harbour in late 1941.
Pushed by the scapegoat-seeking
and profoundly racist Ian
Mackenzie, British Columbia’s
representative in the Mackenzie
King cabinet, the federal
cabinet twelve weeks later
ordered 20,881 Japanese
Canadians removed from all
locations within 160 kilometers
of the Pacific coast. The
pretext was "national security."
The decision was opposed,
as Sunahara puts it, "by
Canada’s senior military
and police officers and
by senior civil servants.
The Royal Canadian Mounted
Police, aware that Japanese
Canadians were controlled
from within by their own
leaders, was confident that
they presented no danger
of sabotage. The military
in Ottawa were equally confident,
having long recognized the
practical impossibility
of an invasion of Canada’s
Pacific Coast."
First,
thousands of women and children,
most born in Canada, were
held in the barns of Vancouver’s
Pacific National Exhibition
while the men were sent
to road camps. Later, 12,000
were confined in detention
camps in the British Columbia
interior. Some kept their
families together by volunteering
to work as sugar beet labourers
in Alberta and Manitoba.
In 1943, the cabinet authorized
the Custodian of Enemy Property
to sell Japanese Canadian
farms, homes and fishing
boats for fire sale prices,
to deduct a disposal fee,
and retain from what was
left whatever had been paid
to the detainees to buy
necessities in the camps.
In the spring of 1945, the
inmates of detention camps
were offered a choice by
Ottawa: immediate resettlement
in Central Canada or repatriation
to a then-starving Japan
at an unspecified date.
In despair, and to keep
their poorly paying jobs
in the detention camps,
almost 7,000 Japanese Canadians
over sixteen signed repatriation
forms. With their 3,500
dependents they represented
43% of Canada’s citizens
of Japanese origin. In November
1945, well after Japan’s
surrender and six weeks
after refusal by the House
of Commons to give the Cabinet
the authority to deport
any resident of Canada,
the King cabinet ordered
the deportation of 10,000
Japanese Canadians. While
lawyers argued the matter
in the courts and the Canadian
public strongly protested,
2,000 Japanese with an equal
number of dependents despaired
of reestablishing themselves
in Canada and sailed for
Japan. Another 4,700 chose
resettlement cast of Alberta.
By 1947, when Ottawa finally
withdrew the deportation
threat, only about 6,800
Japanese Canadians were
left in British Columbia.
The social and career losses,
humiliation and shame could
never be removed. Only in
1949 were the remaining
restrictions lifted from
Japanese Canadians and full
voting rights obtained.
Since
the Second World War, Japanese
Canadians have become Canada’s
third most highly educated
and prosperous minority
after the Jews and the Chinese.
Their restraint, perseverance,
hard work and educational
achievements allowed the
Canadian-born Nisei, in
the 1950s, to win their
rightful place in all fields
of Western Canada society.
Today they are notable in
the professions, trade,
businesses and the arts.
In 1981, 20% of Japanese
Canadians had some university
education compared with
only 16% of the Canadian
population as a whole.
In
1988, after years of lobbying,
Japanese Canadians won from
the Mulroney government
a long overdue apology on
behalf of their fellow citizens
and a compensation package
for internment survivors.
One of the worst periods
in our national history
had finally been addressed.
Jews
Approximately
35,000 of the 246,000 Canadians
who indicated a solely Jewish
origin in the 1986 census
live in Western Canada.
Virtually all of them live
in larger cities, especially
Vancouver and Winnipeg.
Mother 27,000 of part Jewish
origin live in the West.
As most demographers define
Jewishness as essentially
a religious identity, Canadian
Jews should probably not
be described as an ethno-cultural
community at all. Fully
a quarter of respondents
to the 1961 national census
giving Jewish as their religion
refused to designate it
as their cultural origin
as well. On the other hand,
most of the Jewish community
across Canada today was
formed by immigration between
1880 and 1930 of families
from Eastern Europe who
shared a common orthodox
Jewish faith. Later immigrants
also shared a fairly homogeneous
cultural origin.
Jewish
immigration to Western Canada
before 1930, when the Great
Depression all but ended
immigration from anywhere,
originated largely in the
Pale of Settlement located
on the western extremities
of the Russian empire. It
had been established in
the late eighteenth century
to prevent Polish and White
Russian Jews from moving
into the heartland of Russia.
Punitive taxation, a system
of permanent military conscription
for Jewish sons, the sudden
expulsion of Jews from Moscow,
and the pogroms (attacks
on Jewish persons and property)
by officials of the Czar
left approximately 100,000
Russian Jews homeless in
the years 1881-82 alone.
World War I and the 1917
Russian Revolution proved
even more calamitous because
most East European Jews
then lived in the Pale at
the centre of the German-Russian
slaughter. As many as 250,000
Jewish civilians were killed
or starved or froze to death
between 1914 and 1918.
Between
1933 and 1939, anti-semitism
in Ottawa’s political and
bureaucratic circles barred
all but about 4,000 Jews
from entering Canada from
Hitler’s Europe. Bernard
Vigod, the historian, reminds
us that Canada’s performance
here "compares most unfavourably
with that of other countries
in the Western Hemisphere."
After 1948, a wave of displaced
persons, including Jews
who miraculously survived
the Holocaust, were allowed
into Canada. Nearly 7,000
Hungarian Jews arrived after
the 1956 Hungarian uprising
and another 8,000 have come
from the Soviet Union. Thousands
more came during the 1960’s
from Islamic countries.
In
Western Canada, as Stuart
Rosenberg points out in
his book, The Jewish
Community in Canada, "Western
Jews in Saskatchewan, Alberta
and British Columbia feel
themselves to be part of
a single, closely knit regional
family. No matter where
they go or how far from
home they wander, these
Western Canadian Jews always
remain ‘Westerners’....
Canadian Jews in the West
usually do not suffer from
problems of ‘Jewish identity’."
Their
settlement in the West began
in 1883 when 1,300 attempted
to farm at New Jerusalem
near Moosomin, Saskatchewan.
It became a nightmare because
of bad luck, poor organization
and lack of farming experience
|